Just the other day I cycled to the gymnasium as usual for a
bout of physical stimulation and
later that same day I attended a packed meeting in the nearby Oxford University
School of Governance for mental
stimulation. This, together with my work as an Oxford guide and slavishly
following live music in pubs, etc, etc, forms the pattern of my life whilst
residing in this stimulating ‘city of dreaming towers’.
The caricature of an Oxford intellectual has many versions
though there is usually a bicycle involved, also a scarf, a gown and a smattering
of other-worldliness. At that meeting in the School of Governance there were six
academics each presenting their EU funded social science projects. Though professors
at the University they were all fairly young, nicely balanced between the sexes,
skilled PowerPointers, shockingly articulate and terribly enthusiastic. There
were no gowns to be seen, but I did find their projects other-worldly. One presenter
stated that the great thing about European Research Council funding was that it
allowed you to get on with what you wanted to do: his project was to determine
exactly when chickens and pigs and dogs became domesticated. I am not quite
sure who needs this data or who in the EU decided to fund this arcane subject
or why, but I was equally puzzled by most of the other projects. I am sure that
they are of interest to the multinational Oxford teams working on them, I just
don’t seem to have the intellect needed to appreciate their importance.
When I first arrived in Oxford I presumed that the academics
of the University and the city council would be politically conservative. I was
so wrong. The current make-up of Oxford city
council is heavily dominated by Labour (35 out of 48) and not a Conservative in
sight. Also, during the years spent lurking on the fringes of Oxford academia I
could not help but observe its leftward leanings which is seemingly innate and usually
assumed. This seems to indicate to me that I am losing my intellectuality, if I
ever had any, with the advancing years.
Recently the Adam Smith Institute published a survey showing
that this leftward tendency that I have
observed in Oxford seems to exist throughout academia – only 12% of academics
tend to conservatism! When the report surfaced the media Rottweilers
immediately suggested a link with intelligence. Not so, said the survey. The
top 5% in intelligence rating in the country are said to be slightly to the
right – in common with the population as a whole. Since the latter includes me,
the evidence is mounting that I am clearly not an Oxford intellectual
even though I ride a bicycle.
What interests, and worries, me is why this strong and
unrepresentative bias amongst academics should exist. There are many theories. One
is that it is a conspiracy. The left, unable to achieve power through the
ballot box, inveigled themselves into institutions, including academia, and
then took care to keep conservatives out. However, one insightful friend believes that
socialism dominates because the academics are idealists (which squares well
with unwordliness, I suppose). Meanwhile a Spanish friend just completing his
doctorate in Oxford states quite bluntly that it is simply a pretence. My own
view is that it is guilt. Let me explain. Academia is a reasonably well paid
and respected occupation and well buffered from the vicissitudes of the
economy. Unconsciously aware of this they rationalise their guilt into a desire
for a fairer society where everyone could enjoy similar status and stability. Meanwhile,
they are well aware of the horrifying results of imposed socialism in Russia,
China, etc, so they really wish to maintain the status quo: especially the
existence of a conservative government that can be safely criticised from the
high cliffs of academia with little fear of the outbreak of revolution they
pretend to eschew.
In conclusion you can undoubtedly conclude that I am not an
Oxford intellectual and I would be grateful if you would ensure that this blog
does not reach any academic in-tray. In the past week or so I have attended
lectures on: artificial intelligence, global warming, corruption, populism,
Brexit, aging and, of course, the point at which dogs were domesticated. I
would be devastated if denied my intellectual stimulation in Oxford. What could
I do instead: read the Guardian, rejoin the Labour Party, retire to Stow-on-the-Wold,
migrate to the New World, regress to teenage and have my mind reshaped by
academics, volunteer for the one way trip to Mars, or simply welcome the onset
of dementia?
No comments:
Post a Comment
All feedback welcomed. Feel free.