Seventeen years ago we made a big mistake! We bought an old
house with fantastic views in the Spanish village of La Fresneda for less than
you would pay for a Tesla electric car nowadays. We loved it and still love it – so what was
the mistake? Location of course, isn’t it always location? Our village is not
on or near the coast, in fact it’s in the lower part of Aragon which is called
Teruel, a province that the Spanish say “Nobody goes to and nobody comes from”.
No problem there at all, quite the opposite in fact to, say, Oxford or
Barcelona with their dense populations and overbearing popularity with visiting
tourists. And there I’ve said it. Barcelona, that’s the problem, that was our
mistake. The local area in which our village lies is called the Matarraña and on its eastern border is
Catalunia. What’s more, the people of this area look towards Barcelona rather
than the Aragonese capital of Zaragoza, and the people of the Matarraña speak Catalan. Yes Catalan, not
Spanish.
I’m sure you all know that Cataluña leapt onto the world
stage on the first of October 2017 by holding an illegal referendum which asked
the question: should Cataluña leave Spain and become an independent state?
This was not unexpected, and nor was the violence which followed. It is claimed
that nine hundred were injured in the tussles involving what some commentators
called police brutality, yet in this massive conflagration there were only four
cases of hospitalisation – which is odd.
Our own observations were not first hand, but through the
24hours Spanish TV station. And during a day that the government of the country
called a transgression of the constitution, we saw the Catalan police standing back
leaving the national Guardia Civil to face the sectarian fervour. Yes, we did
see policemen battering through glass doorways, throwing a fat old man to the
ground and pulling a woman around by their hair. One shot which was repeated
over and over was of a balding man pointing to the top of his head, the camera
drew closer and closer, but still we could see no sign of injury. However, there
were shots of bleeding faces and of a policeman elbowing someone in the face.
What we did not see is what preceded each of these injuries, but there can be little
doubt that some injuries resulted from unrestrained police reaction and others
from deliberate taunting of the police. Many thought that it would have been better
to allow the referendum to go ahead without resistance and then ignore the
result since it has no legal force – perhaps they were right.
The outcome was declared as a massive victory for
independence from the Catalan government, but the truth is that most voters
stayed at home. A poll taken before the referendum showed that only 40% supported
independence. In fact less than 40% bothered to vote at all and, not surprisingly
these were nearly all secessionists. There is also evidence that in this
uncontrolled referendum where voters could choose their polling station many
chose to vote at more than one! This was clearly not a legal or an electoral
basis for UDI.
Within Spain we have seen massive support for the government’s
stance and the world in general has reacted predictably and mostly in ignorance
of the true situation here. Travelling through Cataluña one can see posters
saying “Welcome to Europe’s newest state”, yet the EU was quick to support the
Spanish constitution. After all they hardly want to give the green light to the
many communities within their member states that would rather be ruled from
Brussels that their own capital cities. In La Fresneda reaction has been muted,
though Margaret tells me that she heard a local character Phillipe shout that
he was both Spanish and Catalan as he argued with the local carpenter over the
matter. Personally I do not know of one person in our area that supports the
secessionists though there must be some. When I ask locals what they think
about the issue they shake their heads and say either ‘mal’ or ‘loco’ – bad or
crazy.
What is little known outside of Spain is that Cataluña,
along with others, is an ‘autonomous community’. This means that the local government
has a control of most important matters, including health, education and
transport, why they even have their own police force, the Mossos. What’s more
they are allowed to impose their own language on children – which itself must contribute
to their sense of separateness. My
grandsons were born and educated in Cataluña. This meant that not only had
they to learn Catalan, they were also taught in it. Think about that for a moment. Naturally they
also have to learn the Spanish national language (here known as Castellano). So
what’s the consequence? Not much time for English, the second language of the
world. In fact only one of our three Spanish grandsons speaks English at all
well.
There are plenty of nice things that can be said of Cataluña and the Catalan culture, but if they succeed in this minority led
quest for independence then they will inherit a damning reputation as the
people who broke up Spain and ruined the Spanish and Catalan economies. And for
what? So that certain politicians can become leaders of a country instead of an
autonomous community. And so that the youngsters inspired by them find that
their prospects are diminished whilst their ‘own’ politicians turn out to be as
divided and untrustable as ‘that lot in Madrid’. Read Orwell’s Animal Farm
young ones – the truth is there.
And our mistake in buying a property in a Catalan speaking
part of Spain? Well, at least I can use it as an excuse for my poor Spanish.
This much bigger mistake, this attempt to divide and destroy a great and
historical nation which takes pride in its diversity cannot be shrugged off so
lightly. Let us just hope theta there will be no more violence.